Stark Realities with Brian McGlinchey

Share this post

America's Insolvency Is Mandatory

starkrealities.substack.com

Discover more from Stark Realities with Brian McGlinchey

Invigoratingly unorthodox perspectives for intellectually honest readers
Over 2,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in

America's Insolvency Is Mandatory

Forget annual budget dramas — federal spending is largely on autopilot and headed for a crash

Brian McGlinchey
Dec 1, 2022
13
Share this post

America's Insolvency Is Mandatory

starkrealities.substack.com
11
Share

In October, the U.S. national debt reached $31 trillion, and the government is projected to wade another trillion dollars into the red in the 2023 fiscal year. The longer-term picture is even gloomier, with the deficit expected to double to $2 trillion by 2030.

Indeed, the longer the horizon, the worse things get. At 98% of Gross Domestic Product, the current national debt is the highest it’s been since just after World War II. On its current course, the debt will soar to 185% of the country’s entire economic output by 2052.

What’s particularly troubling is that the government’s 2022 $1.3 trillion-dollar deficit came at a time of near-record tax intake. At 19.8% of GDP, Uncle Sam’s 2022 tax haul was close to the all-time high of 20.5% set in 1944.

Washington doesn’t have a revenue problem — it has a spending problem.

What few people realize, however, is the extent to which the U.S. government’s disastrous trajectory is on autopilot, thanks to the fact that an ever-larger proportion of federal spending happens without Congressional action.

To understand why, it’s important to first understand that there are two main categories of government spending:

  • Discretionary spending, which requires a vote by Congress as part of the annual appropriations process.

  • Mandatory spending, which is dictated by previously-enacted laws and thus happens without an annual vote in Congress. Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid comprise a big majority of mandatory spending.

Here’s where things have taken an ominous turn. In 1965, mandatory spending accounted for 34% of all federal spending. Today, that share has more than doubled, with mandatory spending representing 71% of federal outlays. With overall spending higher too, mandatory spending is much larger slice of a larger pie.

Spending, Taxes & Deficits: A Book of Charts by Manhattan Institute’s Brian Riedl

As much as it’s right to spotlight wasteful discretionary spending — like a $2.4 million National Science Foundation grant to promote dinosaur enthusiasm or $11.3 million to tell Vietnamese people to stop burning trash — the truth is that the annual budgeting process offers federal legislators a shrinking opportunity to make meaningful fiscal course corrections.

Join more than 2,000 other Stark Realists™ who benefit from striking, ad-free insights

While mandatory spending can be adjusted by passing new laws, there’s a big problem with that: Meaningfully changing the trajectory of mandatory spending requires meaningful adjustments to Social Security and Medicare.

The mere idea arouses indignation among those who’ve been paying taxes into those programs for all their working lives. That’s understandable, since the government fosters the myth that Americans have Social Security and Medicare “accounts.”

However, the truth is that these programs increasingly operate not as savings accounts or insurance plans, but rather as schemes that redistribute money from current workers to retirees. Social Security already dishes out far more in benefits than it takes in via payroll taxes, and Medicare crosses into an annual deficit this fiscal year.

While former Democratic Speaker Tip O’Neill rightly called Social Security the “third rail” of American politics, some Republicans have recently dared to propose touching both it and Medicare.

The Republican Study Committee — a group of House reps — in June of this year floated a budget that suggested:

  • Gradually raising Medicare’s eligibility age to 67 and Social Security’s to 70, and then indexing both to life expectancy

  • Withholding payments from those who retire early and earn more than a certain amount

  • Reducing Social Security payroll taxes and redirecting them to private alternatives

  • Phasing in means-testing for Medicare

Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI) has proposed moving Social Security and Medicare from the mandatory spending category to the discretionary one, so that Congress is compelled to actively monitor and manage the programs — rather than contentedly looking the other way as their mandatory nature digs them deeper into a hole.

Share

As the GOP went out on a political limb, Democrats naturally grabbed their saws. Henry Connelly, a spokesman for Speaker Nancy Pelosi, said “House Republicans are openly threatening to cause an economic catastrophe in order to realize their obsession with slashing Medicare and Social Security.”

The “catastrophe” comment refers to the notion that Republicans may make reform of the programs a condition for raising the federal debt ceiling yet again.

Republicans’ aspirations to reform Social Security and Medicare gave Democrats powerful midterm-election ammunition — with Democrats and allies pushing attack ads portraying the GOP as ruthlessly bent on shrinking the programs, apparently just for the sake of doing so.

President Biden pushed the theme hard down the campaign stretch: “They’re coming after your Social Security and Medicare in a big way,” he warned in stump speeches with congressional candidates.

Without action, however, time is coming for Social Security and Medicare in a big way. Social Security’s trust fund is projected to run out around around 2035. Absent congressional intervention, that will trigger a 20% cut for everyone receiving benefits when the well runs dry. Medicare’s trust fund is projected to vanish in just six years, with less clarity on how shrinking resources will be apportioned.

As close as those two grim milestones are, to politicians of both parties whose principal aim is re-election, they’re critically still more than one election cycle away.

Given that, don’t expect any fruitful action on Social Security or Medicare anytime soon. You can, however, expect that anyone who attempts to tailor the programs to economic reality will be accused of cruel intentions— by disingenuous politicians who portray their own irresponsible inaction as the height of benevolence.

Don’t miss the next enlightening article from Stark Realities with Brian McGlinchey

Support journalism that exposes grim truths about government: Become a supporting subscriber today.

Bookings and media inquiries: email starkrealities [ ] substack [ ] com
Stark Realities with Brian McGlinchey
Social Security Steams Closer to Crisis
At a time when President Biden and congressional Democrats are pushing to expand the breadth of entitlements to include free preschool and subsidized child care, little attention is given to the fact that the country’s biggest existing entitlement program—Social Security—is a financial wreck…
Read more
2 years ago · 4 likes · 2 comments · Brian McGlinchey
Stark Realities with Brian McGlinchey
The Fentanyl Crisis: Brought To You By Drug Prohibition
As drug overdoses continue rising in the United States, one drug has emerged as the most notorious killer of our day: fentanyl. Unfortunately, those clamoring loudest about fentanyl’s death toll support policies that actually bolster its position in the illicit drug trade…
Read more
a year ago · 22 likes · 29 comments · Brian McGlinchey
Stark Realities with Brian McGlinchey
Public Health Erred on the Side of Catastrophe
Throughout the Covid-19 pandemic, proponents of lockdowns, shelter-in-place orders, mask mandates and other coercive government interventions have characterized these measures as benevolently “erring on the side of caution.” Now, as the grim toll of those public health measures comes into ever-sharper focus, it’s increasingly clear those characterizatio…
Read more
2 years ago · 45 likes · 26 comments · Brian McGlinchey
Stark Realities with Brian McGlinchey
How NATO Empire-Building Set the Stage for Crisis Over Ukraine
In his farewell address, George Washington said, “It is our true policy to steer clear of permanent alliances with any portion of the foreign world.” What an offensive notion to Pentagon generals, weapon industry execs, DC think tankers and State Department bureaucrats, who, rather than avoiding permanent alliances, have been relentless in their quest t…
Read more
2 years ago · 11 likes · 10 comments · Brian McGlinchey

Stark Realities with Brian McGlinchey: Invigoratingly unorthodox perspectives for intellectually honest readers

13
Share this post

America's Insolvency Is Mandatory

starkrealities.substack.com
11
Share
11 Comments
Share this discussion

America's Insolvency Is Mandatory

starkrealities.substack.com
Tony Pivetta
Writes Camels & Gnats
Dec 9, 2022

Yes, something has to be done about Social Security and Medicare, but "defense" spending is the one that really sticks in my craw. The U.S. military is beyond overextended: Ukraine, Israel, endless Mideast wars (for Israel), troops in Japan and South Korea, bases in 180 different countries encircling the globe. This is lunacy!

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
ikester8
Dec 5, 2022

Social Security is a true Ponzi scheme, however well intentioned it may have been. As someone who has paid into it for almost 40 years, I'd like to see some returns when I retire but I know the truth that not only are current payments mere transfers, surpluses have been systematically raided by Congress for decades. If anything, the picture is more dire.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
9 more comments...
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 McGlinchey Communications LLC
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing